Side-by-side IB commission analysis: CPA, rebate per lot, revenue share, regulation, and payout terms. Find out which broker pays more for your Introducing Broker network.
| Metric | Tickmill | Vantage |
|---|---|---|
| CPA Range | $200–$600✓ | $200–$600 |
| Max CPA | $600✓ | $600 |
| Rebate/Lot | $5✓ | $5 |
| Revenue Share | 30%✓ | 30% |
| Broker Tier | Tier 2 | Tier 2✓ |
| Regulation | FCA, CySEC✓ | ASIC, VFSC |
| IB Score | 2.5/5✓ | 2.5/5 |
When comparing the CPA (Cost Per Acquisition) model, Tickmill and Vantage take different approaches to attracting new Introducing Brokers. Tickmill offers a CPA range from $200 to $600 per first-time deposit, while Vantage provides a range from $200 to $600. For new IBs building a client base, Tickmill delivers higher earning potential at the entry level. The maximum CPA difference of $0 per FTD can compound significantly when you're acquiring 50+ qualified deposits monthly.
The rebate-per-lot model is where high-volume IBs see exponential earnings growth. Tickmill pays $5 per standard lot traded, while Vantage compensates at $5 per lot. For an IB with clients trading 500 lots daily, the Tickmill advantage translates to $0 per day in incremental revenue. Rebate income is passive and volume-driven, making it ideal for IBs focused on client retention and activity metrics rather than new acquisition.
Revenue share is the long-term wealth builder in the IB ecosystem. Tickmill offers 30% of client commissions, compared to Vantage's 30%. On a mature book with $10M AUM generating $50K in monthly commissions, the Vantage advantage yields $0 additional monthly passive income. This gap widens exponentially as your client base scales, making revenue share the critical metric for 2–5 year IB strategy. IBs who prioritize long-term compounding over immediate CPA payouts should favor Tickmill.
Regulatory oversight directly impacts client confidence, payout reliability, and dispute resolution. Tickmill operates under FCA, CySEC, FSA licenses, while Vantage is regulated by ASIC, VFSC. Tickmill maintains more regulatory redundancy, reducing counterparty risk and ensuring faster commission settlements. Both brokers are Tier 2 operators, but their combination of FCA/ASIC/CySEC coverage signals institutional-grade compliance. When pitching IB programs to high-net-worth traders or corporate accounts, the regulator roster matters—Tickmill edges ahead on trust factors.
Tickmill is a Tier 2 regulated broker offering an IB program with CPA commissions ranging from $200 to $600 per qualifying FTD. The rebate model pays $5 per standard lot traded across all instruments, making it particularly lucrative for IBs with high-frequency trading clients. With 30% revenue share, long-term client relationships generate compounding passive income. The broker operates under FCA, CySEC, FSA licenses and serves clients across EU, UK, APAC.
Vantage is a Tier 2 regulated broker offering an IB program with CPA commissions ranging from $200 to $600 per qualifying FTD. The rebate model pays $5 per standard lot traded across all instruments, making it particularly lucrative for IBs with high-frequency trading clients. With 30% revenue share, long-term client relationships generate compounding passive income. The broker operates under ASIC, VFSC licenses and serves clients across APAC, MENA.
Tickmill leads on CPA commissions, offering up to $600 per FTD versus Vantage's $600. Tickmill wins on rebates at $5/lot, making it the better choice for IBs with high-volume scalping clients. Both brokers are Tier 2-rated and offer competitive revenue share programs. Choose Tickmill if your priority is maximum CPA; choose Tickmill if you have active traders generating 50+ lots per month.
Join BIAFC to manage both IB partnerships with consolidated tracking, merged payouts, and up to +40% CPA boost at Elite tier.
Join BIAFC FreeGet Weekly IB Deals & Rate Updates
Join 2,000+ Forex affiliates. Free broker alerts, commission changes, and exclusive rate boosts.